Milcraft

The Art of Military Innovation (Edward N. Luttwak et al.)

Table of Contents

Copy Doctrine

Practice 1: Build essential forces during active operations

Problem
Waiting for ideal conditions leaves urgent defense needs unmet.

Action
Create simple units and improve them through immediate combat experience.

Outcome
The army gains usable strength while building better methods.

Chapter: Raising an Army under Fire

Practice 2: Turn shortages into focused experiments

Problem
Limited resources prevent the use of standard solutions.

Action
Test affordable ways to meet the most urgent operational need.

Outcome
Scarcity produces simpler solutions that can be fielded quickly.

Chapter: How Scarcity Can Force Innovation

Practice 3: Give young officers real responsibility

Problem
Long promotion paths can delay new ideas and decisive action.

Action
Place capable young officers in command roles early.

Outcome
Fresh experience reaches important decisions faster.

Chapter: A Youthful Officer Corps

Practice 4: Let field units solve local problems

Problem
Central leaders often lack the details needed to fix battlefield problems.

Action
Allow field units to test solutions and report what works.

Outcome
Useful changes spread from direct operational experience.

Chapter: Innovation from Below

Practice 5: Use civilian expertise in reserve units

Problem
A closed military can miss useful knowledge from civilian work.

Action
Assign reservists where their civilian skills can solve military problems.

Outcome
The armed forces gain current technical and professional knowledge.

Chapter: A Reserve Army of Innovators

Practice 6: Connect developers directly with military users

Problem
The distance between industry and soldiers can produce equipment that misses real needs.

Action
Let engineers observe operations and work directly with users.

Outcome
New equipment fits battlefield conditions more closely.

Chapter: A Different Military-Industrial Complex

Practice 7: Develop critical systems in short cycles

Problem
Slow development can make a solution arrive after the threat has changed.

Action
Build, test, and improve critical systems through short development cycles.

Outcome
Effective technology reaches operational units sooner.

Chapter: High-Speed Development: From Missile Boats to Iron Dome

Practice 8: Use the full talent of military women

Problem
Limits on women's roles waste skills that the force needs.

Action
Give qualified women access to technical work and operational responsibility.

Outcome
A broader talent pool produces more useful ideas.

Chapter: IDF Women as Innovators

Practice 9: Keep doctrine open to battlefield evidence

Problem
Rigid doctrine can preserve methods that no longer match the threat.

Action
Revise doctrine when exercises and operations reveal a better approach.

Outcome
Military methods remain useful as conditions change.

Chapter: Military Doctrine and Innovation

Practice 10: Challenge the assumptions behind past victories

Problem
A major victory can make leaders trust methods that an enemy has learned to defeat.

Action
Test successful methods against new enemy capabilities before the next war.

Outcome
The force finds dangerous weaknesses before combat exposes them.

Chapter: From Triumph to Failure in the Air, 1967 and 1973

Practice 11: Combine new technology with new tactics

Problem
Advanced equipment has limited value when old tactics control its use.

Action
Redesign tactics and training around the strengths of new technology.

Outcome
Technological gains become reliable operational power.

Chapter: Airpower Restored with a Technological Leap

Practice 12: Reproduce excellence through demanding training

Problem
Elite performance remains rare when it depends only on exceptional individuals.

Action
Use strict selection and repeated realistic training to build elite units.

Outcome
High performance becomes a repeatable result.

Chapter: Elite Units: The Mass Production of Military Excellence

Practice 13: Back officers who pursue urgent ideas

Problem
Unusual operational needs often receive little support from normal military channels.

Action
Give persistent officers room to build and prove specialized capabilities.

Outcome
Promising ideas can become effective special forces.

Chapter: Military Entrepreneurs and Special Forces

Practice 14: Combine firm discipline with local improvisation

Problem
Strict control alone cannot solve every problem faced by armored units.

Action
Enforce common standards while allowing crews to adapt equipment in the field.

Outcome
Armored units stay coordinated and respond quickly to practical problems.

Chapter: The Armored Corps: Discipline and Technological Improvisation

Practice 15: Design equipment around local combat needs

Problem
Imported designs may protect priorities that do not fit local operations.

Action
Build vehicles around the terrain and crew protection needs of the expected battlefield.

Outcome
The equipment serves the force's actual mission more effectively.

Chapter: Why the Merkava Is Different

Practice 16: Pair intelligence work with rapid engineering

Problem
Intelligence loses value when units cannot quickly turn it into usable tools.

Action
Place analysts and engineers together to solve urgent operational problems.

Outcome
New intelligence capabilities reach users while they still matter.

Chapter: Units 8200 and 81